Monday, 1 October 2007

Te Ara - the conversation continues

The Te Ara conversation has turned into a rich seam, especially from the New Zealand Library community. Last Friday I posted to a couple of the library listservs - who in turn got busy. I offer a sample of their contribution below from Anne Ryan.

"Well, having a bit of time on my hands, I've had a good look at Te Ara today & at Paul's initial blog entry & response. Not working as a "front of house" librarian, I can't comment on how useful it may/may not be as a reference source for the general public. But here's what I found.

First the good points:
* It seems to provide some of the most comprehensive online information on a range of specifically NZ topics. This has to be a 'good thing'.

* The thematic approach appears to be attractive to many users (and there is a reasonable search interface to assist with finding specific topics which are not apparent within the thesaurus structure). This is likely to be attractive to users.

* The option for full or short articles is a good approach (clearly intended for junior users and those wanting a quick answer)

*Good instructions on how to cite articles (obviously targeted to the school researchers)

Now the not so good ones:
*Thematic search approaches also have weakness: Where users don't think of a specific topic as being associated with the larger one -- e.g. Takahe, appear under Large forest birds (these are better known in their habitat of alpine grassland -- and I, for one, didn't think of looking for them under this heading). Another weakness is that there is no cross reference structure under the A-Z search approach (searching for 'Greenstone', I find nothing; I must instead know to search under 'Pounamu'). While this is remedied by use of the keyword search facility, it is still a weakness.

* There appears to be no internal cross-linkages within the individual articles. One of the good features of Wikis. While these linkages are not always useful, they do facilitate a much wider information gathering approach & are more typical of mature internet sources. Basically this looks like a print encyclopedia online. A rather dated approach.

* While the articles are relatively comprehensive, they are not (and cannot be) the entirety of knowledge on a topic. There appears to be little or no linkage to online resources maintained by other organizations or to the 'real world' should the user want to track down 'live' information. For example, in the takahe article there are text references to Tiri Tiri Matangi island (a wildlife refuge where Takahe breed), but no links. The selection of print resources (under 'Further sources'), appears to be eclectic, and there is no indication of where the user might be able to track these down (link to Te Puna?)

*It is clearly a work in progress. It would be useful to have place-markers (once again a wiki concept) to indicate where articles will eventually be written/placed. It would give users an idea of the planned extent of the resource (i.e. whether a topic is in or out of scope)

*Dating online resource information is always a pain.
There is no indication as to what the "updated 21-Sep-2007" actually means. Is this a publication date? Or simply the last time a typo was corrected. While this is not of major importance at the moment (while everything is so new/current), it is likely to cause problems further down the track, with the inability to tell what is current or dated information. I'd like to see publication dates & revision dates indicating intellectual work/review, rather than minor tweaks.

*Finally (and getting back to the blog reaction), the articles are written from a definite perspective (as is all information...), and this has the potential to polarize readers & be perceived as elitist.

A stronger policy of online linking to alternative views, and toning down some of
the rhetoric might be more appropriate (e.g. the statement that "Greenstone is a common term, but increasingly it is being replaced by pounamu" -- is only true within a subset of NZ society -- regardless of whether or not we think it ought to be true).

On the other hand, this is an official, government, source, and perhaps will always demonstrate an official perspective. I'd like to see a much more wiki approach, but understand that this is not the vision of the Te Ara project. Perhaps Paul's vision of pages exported to a study space, may be the way to address the different Perspectives that can be brought to all information topics.
I, too, would be interested in other people's views - and perhaps an analysis of Te Ara as a reference source by an expert (challenge to you reference types out there) "

######
I also advise that John, who started the conversation with his spirited blast on his trumpet- has also responded to my post with a more mellow saxophone. It's an interesting, and thoughtful riposte to my comment, and well worth peoples attention. Inevitably, given my own acknowledged bias, I was especially taken by this part:
######

" I was arguing this is an old-fashioned approach to the web - it's one that I think Paul you have been sceptical of. Web 2.0 didn't rise because someone thought it was a good idea. It arrived as a better alternative to knowledge aggregation and creation.
Maybe that is all I was raving about: Te Ara is so Web 1.0. (I'm not geeky enough to use a statement like that, but you started it...). You get the feeling in another 15 years Te Ara will be the same as it is now - a high-spec brochure sitting on a shelf, waiting for someone to pick it up and browse. Maybe trying ever harder to be more inviting and logical when that user picks it up. But still a brochure written by people who think they know a lot for people who don't.

I am fully in favour of taxpayer funding for stuff that grows the total body of knowledge. But Te Ara doesn't do that.

That's because it is not a source of information unavailable elsewhere. If it added stuff you just can't get elsewhere, then it would be sensational. How would it do that? Maybe it would hand pick its way through links, and it would write original commentary about that material. Plus it would make available source documentation from NZ's archives, museums, libraries and other sources that are currently difficult to access ".

Given the amount of interest this topic has provoked, you should read his whole post. It's here.

Finally, can I report that I am having a session with the editor of Te Ara, Jock Phillips on Wednesday. I will be happy happy to report - he in turn has already said he has found the exchange "hugely interesting". I might even ask him to write a guest post!

In the meantime, I seem to have achieved what I've always hoped for in this blog - a conversation!

11 comments:

Bill said...

I think that Te Ara is a great reference - the articles are well written and authoritative. Yes, I know that its Web 1.0 - but not everyone is sold on Web 2.0 as being a reliable source of information. If you haven't already seen it, have a look at the entry called "The Bush", which is an interesting account of what this term means in New Zealand, with some community contributions added - its a great way of imparting information with added value from public comment.

One grizzle - Te Ara is an incomplete encyclopedia, in progress. Why on earth don't they say so on the home page. Many of the complaints in earlier correspondence have been about things that will probably come later.

chenzhen said...

coach factory outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
oakley sunglasses uk
michael kors outlet clearance
rolex submariner
ed hardy uk
cheap jordan shoes
ray ban outlet store online
birkenstock uk
under armour
adidas superstars
puma outlet
cheap ray bans
omega speedmaster
longchamp outlet store
true religion outlet
cheap jordans
under armour outlet store
nike free flyknit 3.0
polo ralph lauren outlet
pandora charms outlet
cartier love ring
polo ralph lauren outlet online
hollister clothing store
ralph lauren outlet
nike cortez white
reebok shoes
armani exchange
lebron james shoes 2016
cheap jordan shoes
yeezy boost 350 white
ray ban sunglasses outlet
ghd hair dryer
adidas pure boost black
louis vuitton handbags
abercrombie outlet
cheap ray bans
cheap jordan shoes
christian louboutin uk
black timberland boots
chenzhen201677

toko pasutri said...

Terima Kasih Infonya Gan, Sangat Bermanfaat Artikelnya !!!
vimax
vimax asli
selaput dara buatan
ciri ciri vimax asli
obat perangsang wanita
jual obat perangsang cair
blue wizard
obat kuat pria
obat kuat tahan lama
obat viagra
vmenplus
pembesar penis alami
obat pembesar penis
klg pills asli
jual klg pill asli
klg pills
cream pembesar penis
cream kuda jantan
vagina getar
klg
klg usa asli
vagina senter
klg asli
obat pengemuk badan
obat peninggi badan
alat penggeli vagina
alat pembesar penis
vakum pembesar penis
terapi pembesar penis
vimax kapsul
obat kuat nangen
obat kuat herbal
potenzol cair

hoxn Ln said...

A general view on the final day of Watches Replica the Cartier International Dubai Polo Challenge 10th edition at Desert Palm Hotel on February 21, Replica Rolex watches 2015 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.UAE play Desert Palm on the final day of the UK Replica watches International Dubai Polo Challenge 10th edition at Desert Palm Hotel on Replica Rolex Watches February 21, 2015 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.A model in the Cartier Villa on the final day of Designer handbags.

Vimax Asli Makassar said...

Vimax Asli Makassar

Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bogor said...

Vimax Original Asli Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Solo
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Vimax Asli Di Makassar
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Solo
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Batam
Jual Perangsang potenzol Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Potenzol Obat Perangsang Wanita Di Solo
Jual Perangsang Blue Wizard Di Lampung

Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bogor said...

Vimax Original Asli Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Solo
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Bogor
Jual Vimax Asli Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Vimax Asli Di Makassar
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Solo
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Batam
Jual Perangsang potenzol Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Potenzol Obat Perangsang Wanita Di Solo
Jual Perangsang Blue Wizard Di Lampung

chenmeinv0 said...

birkenstock outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
air max uk
jordan shoes
adidas stan smith shoes
nike blazer high
christian louboutin pumps
columbia outlet online
le coq sportif chaussures
2017.5.2xukaimin

Anonymous said...

Jual Perangsang potenzol Di Bandar Lampung
Jual Potenzol Obat Perangsang Wanita Di Solo
Jual Perangsang Blue Wizard Di Lampung
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Makassar
Jual Tital Gel Asli Di Bogor
Jual Obat Kuat Viagra Di Makassar
Jual Hammer of Thor Di Solo
Jual Minyak Lintah Papua Di Solo
Jual Minyak Lintah Papua Di Bogor
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Malaysia
Jual Hammer Of Thor Di Denpasar

Pantangan Makana Diabetes Melitus said...

It is good we use in herbal medicine, as they may awake to the authenticity of the drug product :)


Pengertian Sampai Cara Pencegahan Diabetes Melitus
Cara Ampuh Mengatasi Sariawan
Pengobatan Jantung Bengkak Alami
Pengobatan Yang Ampuh Untuk Kanker Mulut
Pengobatan Radang Amandel Sampai Sembuh
Obat Herbal Alami Pembersih Rahim Pasca Keguguran

arief shop said...




Vimax Bandung
Hammer Of Thor Bandung
Klg Bandung
Penirum Bandung
Erogan Bandung
Obat Forex Bandung
Testo Ultra Bandung
Titan Gel Bandung